A Panamanian court has sentenced resident engineer Nelkys Gotti to five years in prison for negligent homicide, delivering a landmark ruling in a Panama construction negligence case that dates back to a deadly 2018 parking garage collapse at the PH Breeze residential tower in Costa del Este. The sentence, announced Wednesday, also suspends Constructora Corcione & Asociados, S.A. from operating nationally for the same period and orders combined civil damages of $4,285,811.11.
The ruling stems from a March 28, 2018 incident in which a red Mini Cooper fell 14 meters from the fourth level of the building’s parking structure onto a public street, killing three people and leaving one survivor with permanent spinal cord injuries. The Ministry of Public Affairs confirmed the verdict was obtained by the Homicide and Femicide Section of the Metropolitan Prosecutor’s Office.

Panama Construction Negligence and Safety Code Violations
Prosecutors established that the residential complex was built between 2008 and 2011 without meeting minimum safety requirements outlined in Panama’s Structural Design Regulation of 2004 (REP-2004). The investigation found that both the construction company and the resident engineer failed to observe their duty of care during the building’s construction phase.
The criminal penalty includes an additional one-year ban preventing Gotti from practicing civil engineering once her main sentence is completed. The civil damages were divided into three separate awards for the victims’ families, totaling $1,615,811.11, $900,000.00, and $1,770,000.00 respectively.

Fatal Incident Details and Victim Impact
The victims included a father, his daughter, and a 20-year-old man. Sabrina Murillo, the sole survivor of the tragedy, sustained a permanent spinal cord injury. Following the verdict, Murillo expressed relief at the outcome, stating that justice had finally been served after years of legal proceedings.
The defense team and Constructora Corcione & Asociados, S.A. issued a joint statement rejecting responsibility and announcing plans to appeal the first-instance ruling. Their account of the incident differs significantly from the prosecution’s narrative.
Defense Arguments and Company Response
According to the company’s legal team, the vehicle was driven by a 16-year-old without a license or driving permit. The defense claims the driver lost control on the central ramp at level 400 and accelerated through an unassigned parking space at speeds exceeding 30 kilometers per hour. Expert calculations cited by the company suggest the car struck a concrete barrier with force greater than 10.6 tons, propelling it approximately six meters horizontally before the fatal fall.
Constructora Corcione maintains that the project was executed between 2008 and 2010 according to plans designed by architect Eduard McGrath and approved by competent authorities. The building received its occupancy permit in July 2010 following inspections by the Municipality of Panama and the Fire Department. The company also noted that the project won the Magno Award 2011 from the Panamanian Society of Engineers and Architects (SPIA).
#20Nov | Una corte de Panamá sentenció a cinco años de prisión a una ingeniera civil e inhabilitó por ese mismo tiempo a la empresa constructora en la que trabajaba por la muerte de dos ciudadanos venezolanos y un costarricense en marzo de 2018, cuando el vehículo que ocupaban cayó al vacío desde el cuarto piso del estacionamiento de un edificio residencial. Tanto la ingeniera como la empresa fueron declaradas culpables del delito de homicidio culposo el 28 de octubre, y la sentencia fue dictada ayer, según informó el Ministerio Público de Panamá. Además de la pena de cinco años de prisión, la ingeniera fue inhabilitada para ejercer la ingeniería civil por un año, una vez cumplida la pena principal. 🗞️: @EFEnoticias
— El Diario (@eldiario) November 20, 2026
In its defense, the firm pointed out that specific regulations concerning vehicular barriers were only issued by the Technical Board of Engineering and Architecture (JTIA) through Resolution No. JTIA 016 on April 11, 2018, eight years after project completion. The company has requested that authorities also evaluate the responsibility of the guardians of the minor who was driving the vehicle at the time of the incident.
The appeal process will determine whether the conviction and civil penalties withstand judicial review in higher courts.

